Murder Trial Opens with a Gang-Exit Defense
Monroe UnfilteredThe murder trial of Matthew Morales opened Tuesday with two very different stories about what happened in the smoking area of a Middle Smithfield Township bar. No verdict had been reported as of Wednesday night.
Morales, 33, of Tobyhanna Township, is charged with criminal homicide and two felony firearms counts in the May 24, 2024, shooting death of Henry Koroma Jr. at My Place Bar & Grill on Milford Road. In his opening statement, Monroe County District Attorney Michael Mancuso told jurors the shooting was captured by several surveillance cameras in an area of the bar known as the “Chicken Coop,” according to the Pocono Record. Mancuso said a fight broke out when Koroma's girlfriend attacked a woman who was with Morales, that Morales pulled a gun, briefly left the fight, then came back and raised and lowered the gun several times before it fired. He also pointed to texts in which Morales told Koroma he was “willing to risk it all.”
Defense attorney Alex Ward told the jury a different story. He said both men belonged to the Jets, a set of the Bloods gang, and that Morales, who joined at 17 and went to federal prison in 2015, had been trying to get out. Ward said Morales feared that leaving the gang meant his own blood would have to be spilled, and that he skipped what was supposed to be his exit meeting at an East Stroudsburg bar that day. According to Ward, the group then found Morales at My Place, Koroma threw the first punch, and Morales, whose gun was not loaded at first, loaded it and fired only after he ran out of ways to get away.
Co-defendant Raymond Batiste, 40, faces two felony counts of hindering apprehension. Mancuso said Batiste picked up shell casings and drove Morales to Allentown without helping Koroma. Batiste's attorney, Chief Public Defender Jason LaBar, called his client the “third wheel in the worst position ever” and said there is no evidence he picked up any casings. Police didn't find Morales until August 2024, after he was shot eight times at a Salt Lake City nightclub and survived.
Both men are presumed innocent until proven guilty. Opening statements are not evidence; the jury will decide which version of that night holds up. We'll report the verdict.
This story on its own page →

